Christian Nationalism vs The Bill of Rights

This week I can’t offer anything better than my brother Jim’s post. He has powerfully articulated the challenge we face as Christians and Americans. So this week’s Monday Memo come from him. Thanks, Bro, for a powerful word. –Jack Harnish


Christian Nationalism vs The Bill of Rights

Last week Elizabeth Johnson Jr. was finally exonerated for her 1693 conviction for witchcraft.

The Salem Witch trials (1692-1693) were a Puritan inquisition that resulted in the deaths of 25 men and women, 19 of whom were hanged, five died in jail and one was crushed with rocks.

Johnson was 22 when she was accused and convicted, perhaps because of a mental disability or because she never married or had children. The governor of Massachusetts granted her a reprieve from hanging because of “shadowy evidence.” She died in 1747 at the age of 77. But her conviction was never overturned. It came as the result of a three-year effort by the eighth-grade civics class at North Andover Middle School and their teacher, Carrie LaPierre.  

So, what might we learn from Elizabeth Johnson’s story today?

The Evil of “Christian Nationalism”

After 329 years, haven’t we learned how badly things can go wrong when Christians use the power of the law to impose their theological convictions on their community? Make no mistake: the witch trials were a deadly result of the merger of religion and government.

One of the sad ironies in our history is that Christians who came to America to escape persecution quickly became persecutors. In setting out to create a Christian community, they used the power of the law to force others to deny their conscience in order to obey their Puritan interpretations of scripture.

I highly recommend John M. Barry’s powerful book, Roger Williams and the Creation of the American Soul: Church, State, and the Birth of Liberty.

That’s why Christian nationalism is an oxymoronic label for a political movement that is just as damaging to Christianity and it is to the nation.

But the evil of “Christian nationalism” is very much alive among us. It was viciously on display during the January 6 insurrection. We saw it this weekend in CPAC’s celebration of Hungary’s anti-democratic, Christian nationalist dictator, Viktor Orbán. It’s on the ballot with candidates like Marjorie Taylor Greene and in the election of local school boards.

The “Five Freedoms” enshrined in the First Amendment — freedom of speech, religion, the press, assembly, and the right to petition the government — guarantee that as a follower of Christ my voice can be heard in the public debate, but they do not guarantee that my voice will drown out other voices or that my convictions should be imposed by law on others. Democracy means that the freedom I claim for myself is measured by the freedom I protect for others. It means that sometimes I win, and sometimes I lose, but we keep on working together to become “a more perfect union.”

I’m convinced that I can be a Christian or I can be a “Christian nationalist,” but I can’t be both.

That’s what Elizabeth Johnson taught me. May she rest in peace.

Grace and Peace,


3 thoughts on “Christian Nationalism vs The Bill of Rights

  1. Stevel Thomas

    What is described as Christian nationalism is today often what would be defined as Fascism and is a threat to demo/cracy in the United States.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s